Hawaii Living

3251 Aina Mahiai Pl (Kaanapali)

1 / 39
Photo 1 of 3251 Aina Mahiai Pl, Lahaina
Photo 2 of 3251 Aina Mahiai Pl, Lahaina
Photo 3 of 3251 Aina Mahiai Pl, Lahaina
3251 Aina Mahiai Pl, Lahaina
Selling or Buying in Kaanapali?
Fill out the form below and an agent with expertise in Kaanapali will contact you shortly.
Description
Step into a recently completed new construction home in the exclusive, gated Kaanapali Coffee Farms neighborhood—no need to worry about the hassles of building or permits, instead, save two years of your life with this incredible opportunity! The time you'll save by moving into this brand-new home can be spent soaking in sunsets, lounging on the plantation-style lanai, and enjoying beach days without a care. Situated on 4.68 acres of lush coffee trees and open space for ultimate privacy, this home exudes a modern plantation vibe with high vaulted ceilings and a spacious deck perfect for outdoor living. The open floor plan of the kitchen and living area extends to a front lanai, where you can take in breathtaking ocean and island views. With a total of 2,698 square feet, this home includes 4 bedrooms, 3.5 baths, and a sunroom that’s ideal for an office or reading nook. The gourmet kitchen features a large pass-through window that opens to a 634-square-foot covered lanai, perfect for entertaining. Two separate garages—a 2-car garage attached to the house with storage and a 352-square-foot detached garage—provide ample space for all your toys or agricultural needs. Included with the home is an active pool permit already approved with Maui County. Come explore Kaanapali Coffee Farms and see what makes this place so special!
Past Activity
  • Nov 18, 2024 Sold for $4,200,000
  • Oct 23, 2024 Under Contract
  • Feb 26, 2024 Listed at $4,995,000
More Details
  • Owner, Tax & Resale History
  • HOA Fees / ft²: $0.22
  • Price / ft²: $1,557
  • View: Ocean
  • Security Features: Smoke Detector(s)
  • TMK: 2440200130000
  • Courtesy: Compass / 808-283-7214
  • MLS: 401303
About Kaanapali
  • About 15% of Kaanapali's residential real estate is single-family homes and 85% are condos.
     
  • Kaanapali is Hawaii's 1st master-planned community, adding its first single-family home subdivision, Kaanapali Vista, in 1971. 15% of Kaanapali's residential real estate is single-family homes. The remaining 85% are condos.
     
  • Amfac, Inc. (formerly American Factors) began development in 1959 and is still seeing it through today in its reorganized form, Kaanapali Land.
     
  • The homes comes in a variety of settings, including beachfront and hillside



  ... Read more
The MLS properties are based on information from the Multiple Listing Service of REALTORS® Association of Maui. Listings last updated on January 30, 2026.Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
Other Kaanapali Homes
$4,495,000
26 E Mahi Pua Pl
4 Bds | 4.5 Ba
4,415 ft²
$4,425,000
27 Kaulele Pl
4 Bds | 4.5 Ba
2,675 ft²
$4,200,000
24 Anapuni Lp#2
4 Bds | 4 Ba
3,585 ft²
$4,995,000
837 Anapuni Lp
4 Bds | 5 Ba
3,710 ft²
Other Maui Homes
Kapalua
$4,950,000
116 Pulelehua St#1
4 Bds | 4.5 Ba
4,081 ft²
Napili & Kahana
$3,249,000
5045 Lower Honoapiilani Rd#9
4 Bds | 5 Ba
2,813 ft²
Launiupoko
$3,199,000
235 Wailau Pl
4 Bds | 3.5 Ba
2,760 ft²
Kapalua
$5,395,000
104 Woodrose Pl
4 Bds | 3.5 Ba
3,315 ft²
Kula
$4,650,000
173 Huahua Pl
5 Bds | 5 Ba
3,593 ft²
Kula
$4,749,000
40 Pulehu Nui Rd
5 Bds | 2.5 Ba
3,619 ft²
  • Sold 11/18/24 at $4,200,000
    (List Price: $4,595,000)
Description
Step into a recently completed new construction home in the exclusive, gated Kaanapali Coffee Farms neighborhood—no need to worry about the hassles of building or permits, instead, save two years of your life with this incredible opportunity! The time you'll save by moving into this brand-new home can be spent soaking in sunsets, lounging on the plantation-style lanai, and enjoying beach days without a care. Situated on 4.68 acres of lush coffee trees and open space for ultimate privacy, this home exudes a modern plantation vibe with high vaulted ceilings and a spacious deck perfect for outdoor living. The open floor plan of the kitchen and living area extends to a front lanai, where you can take in breathtaking ocean and island views. With a total of 2,698 square feet, this home includes 4 bedrooms, 3.5 baths, and a sunroom that’s ideal for an office or reading nook. The gourmet kitchen features a large pass-through window that opens to a 634-square-foot covered lanai, perfect for entertaining. Two separate garages—a 2-car garage attached to the house with storage and a 352-square-foot detached garage—provide ample space for all your toys or agricultural needs. Included with the home is an active pool permit already approved with Maui County. Come explore Kaanapali Coffee Farms and see what makes this place so special!
    The MLS properties are based on information from the Multiple Listing Service of REALTORS® Association of Maui. Listings last updated on January 30, 2026.Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
    • Nov 18, 2024 Sold for $4,200,000
    • Oct 23, 2024 Under Contract
    • Feb 26, 2024 Listed at $4,995,000
    • About 15% of Kaanapali's residential real estate is single-family homes and 85% are condos.
       
    • Kaanapali is Hawaii's 1st master-planned community, adding its first single-family home subdivision, Kaanapali Vista, in 1971. 15% of Kaanapali's residential real estate is single-family homes. The remaining 85% are condos.
       
    • Amfac, Inc. (formerly American Factors) began development in 1959 and is still seeing it through today in its reorganized form, Kaanapali Land.
       
    • The homes comes in a variety of settings, including beachfront and hillside



      ... Read more
    Other Kaanapali Homes
    $4,495,000
    26 E Mahi Pua Pl
    4 Bds | 4.5 Ba
    4,415 ft²
    $4,425,000
    27 Kaulele Pl
    4 Bds | 4.5 Ba
    2,675 ft²
    $4,200,000
    24 Anapuni Lp#2
    4 Bds | 4 Ba
    3,585 ft²
    $4,995,000
    837 Anapuni Lp
    4 Bds | 5 Ba
    3,710 ft²
     
    You do not own the land, but have the right to use the land until an expiration year. At expiration the ownership typically reverts back to the land owner.
    Buyer and Seller have reached an agreement and are under contract. The sale may be subject to one or more contingencies.
    We have handled many transactions for clients who purchase Hawaii real estate without visiting. By request, our network of agents can prepare thorough property videos to ensure you are familiar with every detail necessary. All documents can be signed remotely.
    Buyer and Seller have reached an agreement and are under contract. The sale is expected to close / record soon.
    We will be happy to work with you as a Buyer's agent. Call us to learn more: 808-943-9000.
    Note: A Seller's agent has a fiduciary responsibility towards the Seller. Working with a Buyer's agent objectives and goals are aligned, at no cost to you, the Buyer.
    Other fees could be a special assessment, reserve contributions etc.
    DOM = Days On Market. Our site shows listings immediately. A brand new listing may show DOM 2 or 3 days, if listing agent did not upload the same day listing agreement was executed.
    Includes estimated monthly mortgage payment, maintenance / HOA fees & property taxes. The estimate does not include insurance premiums.